CATHOLIC NEWS OF THE WEEK . Saturday, 8 December 2018

Print Version    Email to Friend
Confessional seal may be unconstitutional

DOVER (CWNews.com): A superior court judge in Delaware, the United States of America, has questioned the constitutionality of a state law that protects the secrecy of sacramental confession.

State law mandates the reporting of suspected child abuse except in cases covered by the attorney-client privilege and conversations “between priest and penitent in sacramental confession.”

Ruling in a case involving the failure of elders of the Jehovah’s Witnesses to report child abuse on January 26, the presiding judge, Mary Johnston, said that if priest, penitent and sacramental confession are interpreted narrowly, then the law is unconstitutional, because its effect would be to advance certain religions over others.

But Johnston clarified her remarks saying that if the law is interpreted broadly to include confidential conversations in which members of any religious body express sorrow for their deeds to their religious leaders, then a ruling that the law is unconstitutional could be avoided.

 

“A broader reading may be justified, because the terms at issue are neither defined nor upper case,” she concluded.

More from this section